The ideal stage model is the fastest way to make stagetostage calculations. Because a total condenser is used, the vapor leaving. It plots the classic mccabethiele diagram and evaluates the minimum and actual reflux ratio, and the thermodynamic state of the feed. You can manipulate some of the data and see the immediate graphical changes, which kinda puts the method into perspective a bit more clearly. The mccabethiele diagram enabled decades of effective design and operational analysis of distillation columns, and has been used to teach several generations of chemical engineers to design and troubleshoot distillation and other cascaded processes. Pdf mccabethiele method revisitedsolving binary distillation. As this is a binary system, the mccabe thiele method described in section 11. Uses the mccabe thiele graphical method to determine the number of equilibrium stages in a distillation column. All three will lie on the saturated liquid line, b at x b 0. This information can be used to create enthalpyconcentration and equilibrium diagrams. Use of the mccabethiele method for solving destillation problems.
By the use of the mccabethiele method and the advantage of a solvepackage mathead tm, a procedure is proposed to solve problems. Relative volatility is 5 reflux ratio mccabe thiele method 1. Mccabethiele method revisitedsolving binary distillation problems with nonconventional specifications article pdf available in journal of chemical engineering of. The distillate, feed and bottom mole fractions are 0. The mccabethiele method is considered to be the simplest and perhaps most instructive method for the analysis of binary distillation.
Multiple feeds total condenser feed 1 overhead vapor boilup distillation column multiple feeds reflux drum bottoms partial reboiler reflux distillate feed 2 the mccabe thiele method for cascades can be applied to systems with more than two sections. Stepping off stages course description learncheme features faculty prepared engineering education resources for students and instructors produced by the department of chemical and biological engineering at the university of colorado boulder and funded by the national science foundation, shell, and the engineering excellence fund. This application calculates the required number of theoretical stages for a set of specified operating parameters via the mccabe thiele method. I think this spreadsheet is stunningly helpful for understanding the mccabethiele method for the analysis of binary distillation. The feed is a two phase mixture with a feed quality is equal to 0. A unit operation is one step in a process to convert a raw material into some useful chemical product. The mccabethiele method is an approximate graphical tray by tray method for the design of distillation columns t hat may provide a clear picture of what i s happening in a distillation column. Review of binary distillation mccabethiele by computer. This demonstration presents the mccabethiele graphical method applied to the waterethanol mixture.
A 100 kmolhr stream of ethanol 50 mol% and npropanol 50 mol% is fed to a continuous distillation column at room temperature 298 k and atmospheric. Thiele in an article titled graphical design of fractionating columns. Mccabethiele method posted in chemical process simulation. A 100 kmolhr stream of ethanol 50 mol% and npropanol 50 mol% is fed to a continuous distillation column at room temperature 298 k and atmospheric pressure. Separation methods, system diagrams, nonideal mixtures, solving an exercise with mccabe thieles graphical method there is a newer video where. It is used as an introductory method to teach the design of distillation and is still in use today by engineers who design distillation columns. The program is written in qbasic and has been adapted to run on a pc computer msdos. This also ensures the operating lines are straight lines.
We may also elect to select the mccabe thiele panel. Thus, this paper details a method for generating a mccabe thiele diagram using microsoft excel. An example of the mccabethiele diagram for absorption is illustrated in figure 8. For convenience, figure xv is included to show that a small shift in the origin of the operating line due to an increase in copper tenor of stripped organic, necessitates an increase in oa ratio if the same. Jul 25, 2007 the feed is a two phase mixture with a feed quality is equal to 0. Mccabe thiele in excel i am trying to findcreate a spreadsheet which draws a neat graph of a mccabe thiele diagramm by specifying xy equilibrium data, reflux ratio, top and bottom purities and feed quality. At undergraduate level, the separation of binary mixtures is studied using, mainly, the mccabe. Che396 senior design distillation 8 assumptions the following assumptions are implied when using this method mccabe, 1993. Mccabethiele method when constant molar overflow does not apply. To do this, you make a plot showing the equilibrium curve, feed line, and operating lines for the rectifying and stripping sections all on the same axes, and then find answers by graphical construction.
Mccabethiele method for an ideal binary mixture file. Hence, the effect on the mccabe thiele is obvious by reference to any of the constructions in previous illustrations, e. However, most of the applications are limited to problems where extreme top and bottom compositions and reflux ratio are specified and the objective is to determinate the number of stages. For a good overview of the mccabe thiele method as applied to binary distillation problems, see geankoplis 1, pages 706724. Distillation calculations can be performed graphically on an enthalpyconcentration hx diagram. Chg 3111 winter 2017 practice problems in distillation part a. Review and extension of the mccabethiele method covering multiple feeds, products and heat transfer stages a. The mccabe thiele method allows full control over reboiler duty, and it is not uncommon to first solve a problem assuming minimum reflux ratio. The desired composition of the bottoms and distillate d. Thiele method because of the advantage to present the results in.
At undergraduate level, the separation of binary mixtures is studied using, mainly. Results can be scaled to actual reflux ratio, typically r 1. The mccabe thiele method is a graphical procedure to solve alternately the equilibrium relation and the material. Try your hand at a sample mccabethiele problem and learn how to approximate equilibrium stages and reflux ratio with aiches distillation in. Absorption and stripping in addition to the distillation, there are other unit operations used for separating substances absorption is the unit operation in which one or more components of a gas stream are removed from the gas mixture by being absorbed onto a nonvolatile liquid called a solvent in this case, the solvent is the separating. Mccabethiele graphical method for a nonideal binary mixture. Experienced process engineers often use mccabe thiele diagrams to understand or help debug simulation results 3. The mccabe thiele method was published 90 years ago by warren l. Please can anyone help me how to obtain the number of trays and reflux ratio using the mccabethiele method for this example. First, the rectifying cyan and stripping magenta operating lines are plotted using a reflux ratio equal to 1. Mccabe thiele method for an ideal binary mixture in matlab. Describe the distillation process determine the vapour liquid equilibrium vle data for a binary mixture determine the number of stages required to achieve a specified separation using the mccabe.
The mccabe thiele method is an approximate graphical tray by tray method for the design of distillation columns t hat may provide a clear picture of what i s happening in a distillation column. With the mccabe thiele method, the total number of. First, the rectifying and stripping operating lines are plotted using a reflux ratio equal to 1. It is a method for calculating the number of theoretical trays required for the distillation of a binary mixture. Vs mccabe thiele method assumes that molar vapor and liquid flow rates are constant in each section of the column constant molar overflow eliminates the need to make an energy balance around each stage for nonideal binary mixtures, such an assumption may not be valid and the mccabe thiele method may not be accurate. The method follows the here below sequence of steps. Please can anyone help me how to obtain the number of trays and reflux ratio using the mccabe thiele method for this example.
Hence, the effect on the mccabethiele is obvious by reference to any of the constructions in previous illustrations, e. Mccabethiele method mass transfer solved problems msubbu free download as pdf file. When used with the mccabe thiele method, which is said to be the simplest and perhaps most instructive method for the analysis of binary distillation, the combination is formidable. Working on the hx diagram is more general than a mccabe thiele construction, because it takes direct account of the thermal effects and does not require an assumption of equimolal overflow. Mccabethiele method gui for binary column distillation. Use of the mccabethiele method for solving destillation problems with. The mccabe thiele method is a graphical procedure to solve alternately the. However, convergence becomes more difficult as the equilibrium and enthalpy data. Mccabethiele method when constant molar overflow does. Mccabethiele graphical method example part 1 youtube. Mccabethiele graphical method for a nonideal binary.
Reflections on the use of the mccabe and thiele method. In the last example, the relative volatility is close to that of odichlorobenzene and. This application also highlights several maple concepts. This article describes how to apply the mccabe thiele method. Mccabethiele method revisitedsolving binary distillation. Effect of relative volatility on number of stages 100 kgmolehr of a mixture containing 50 mole percent a and 50 mole percent b is to be fractionated to a distillate containing 90 mole percent a and a residue containing 90 mole percent b using a total condenser and feed at its saturated liquid condition. Eventually the scope of the application will include other types of chemical process separations which use the mccabe thiele method as well as nonideal separation equipment. Mccabethiele method revisitedsolving binary distillation problems with nonconventional specifications article pdf available in journal of chemical engineering of japan 419. Then, part 2 of this exercise, consists in determining the ratio of rectifying to stripping stages regarding the same mixture and operational conditions, using the fenske equation, the kirkbridge equation and the mccabe and thiele method.
The mccabethiele method of distillation design is a graphical method of design that dates back to the early 20 th century. The graphical mccabethiele method can be used to determine the number of ideal stages and feed tray location. Aug 15, 2010 a friend suggested i publish the initial version and get community feedback before continuing as progress has somewhat stagnated. We may also elect to select the mccabethiele panel.
Reyeslabarta abstract the mccabethiele method is a classical approximate graphical method for the conceptual design of binary distillation columns which is still widely used, mainly for. This excel spreadsheet for mccabethiele method is awesome. Yet some consider graphical techniques tools of the past, and as a result, the distillation column has become a black box and. A seminar on distillation column design using mccabe thiele method. This demonstration presents the mccabe thiele graphical method applied to the waterethanol mixture. By the use of the mccabethiele method and the advantage of a solvepackage mathcad, a procedure is proposed to solve problems with different.
Mccabethiele method revisited solving binary distillation problems with nonconventional specifications article pdf available in journal of chemical engineering of japan 419. I think this spreadsheet is stunningly helpful for understanding the mccabe thiele method for the analysis of binary distillation. Mccabe thiele method developed in 1925 suitable for binary mixtures in continuous columns can be used as a preliminary study for multi component combination of vle data and operating lines assumes. In addition, you will also learn about specification and selection of the appropriate distillation hardware. Modified ponchonsavarit and mccabe thiele methods for download as pdf file. It uses the fact that the composition at each theoretical tray or equilibrium stage is completely determined by the mole fraction of one of the two components and is based on the assumption of constant molar. Learn essential distillation concepts likely to be faced by process support, operations and process design engineering personnel. The molar flow rates of the vapor and liquid are nearly constant in each section of the column.
This demonstration presents the mccabe and thiele graphical method, which is applicable to binary mixtures. Mccabe thiele method posted in chemical process simulation. A mccabe thiele diagram can be obtained by clicking on the mccabe thiele icon on the button bar. The mccabethiele method was published 90 years ago by warren l.
Its one of the blackboxes which appeared in process and performs some physical as opposed to chemical change. The popular mccabethiele 5 graphical method is an example of this approach. Part of the liquid from the bottom tray is vaporized in the reboiler and returned to the. Constant molaloverflow no heat loss from column not suitable if. A mccabethiele diagram for the absorption operation from separation process engineering by wankat, 2007 note that the operating line in the mccabethiele diagram for absorption is above the equilibrium line. Practice problems in distillation practice problems in. Mccabe thiele plots provide a simple, graphical tool for the analysis of binary.
Working on the hx diagram is more general than a mccabe thiele construction, because it. This approach is sometimes called the ponchonsavarit method. Mccabethiele method mass transfer solved problems msubbu. The program computes the number of equilibrium stages for a binary ideal mixture with relative volatility equal to 2. This application calculates the required number of theoretical stages for a set of specified operating parameters via the mccabethiele method. After the lecture on march 6 th, we have covered the material needed to solve problems 1, 2a and b, and 3a, and to start setting up 3d. From the data tables or from the hx diagram find the enthalpy of the distillate, h d 3050 calgmol. The method, we are going to illustrate in this section, is known under the name of fenskeunderwoodgilliland fug, from the three guys which developed the three different parts of the method in order to get the ideal number of stages of a multicomponent distillation column. Relative volatility is 5 reflux ratio mccabe thiele diagram as an essential tool for understanding and analyzing cascaded operations. We draw the mccabe and thiele diagram and get the number of theoretical plates equal to 9. Mccabe thiele distillation separation processes free 30. It plots the classic mccabe thiele diagram and evaluates the minimum and actual reflux ratio, and the thermodynamic state of the feed.
The mccabethiele method allows full control over reboiler duty, and it is not uncommon to first solve a problem assuming minimum reflux ratio. Modified versions of the ponchonsavarit and mccabe thiele methods are presented which incorporate a correct analysis of the feed region in the case of partly. Mccabe thiele free download as powerpoint presentation. A mccabethiele diagram can be obtained by clicking on the mccabethiele icon on the button bar. Kirkbridge equation and the mccabe and thiele method. A mccabe thiele plot is a simplified tool to assist in understanding distillation. It uses the fact that the composition at each theoretical tray or equilibrium stage is completely determined by the mole fraction of one of the two components and is based on the assumption of constant molar overflow which requires that. Modified ponchonsavarit and mccabethiele methods for download as pdf file. The following matlab project contains the source code and matlab examples used for mccabe thiele method for an ideal binary mixture. Lines 4090 request inputs for the coefficients a, b and c of eq. Vs mccabethiele method assumes that molar vapor and liquid flow rates are constant in each section of the column constant molar overflow eliminates the need to make an energy balance around each stage for nonideal binary mixtures, such an assumption may not be valid and the mccabethiele method may not be accurate. When used with the mccabethiele method, which is said to be the simplest and perhaps most instructive method for the analysis of binary distillation, the combination is formidable.
662 538 83 902 1190 342 281 1304 855 1164 387 1601 321 638 1563 1116 1032 595 939 964 1200 202 159 225 1021 605 611 1221 1159 1643 1626 192 265 39 1305 430 1378 244 436 984 300 727 1328 680 1471